Pathfinder Fans Warned About Misleading Amazon Listings, Check Editions Carefully
A highly upvoted Reddit thread on r/Pathfinder2e raised alarms on December 28 about Amazon search results that appeared to list Paizo core rulebooks at unusually low prices, while failing to clearly identify edition or pocket format. The reports matter because buyers risk ordering the wrong edition or a compact pocket edition without realizing it, and community members are urging careful checks and reporting of suspect listings.
On December 28 a Reddit post on r/Pathfinder2e drew wide attention by documenting a series of Amazon listings for Paizo core books that users described as misleading. Posters shared screenshots showing search results that surfaced entries priced around $29.99 that looked like regular core books at a glance, yet were either pocket editions or lacked clear edition labeling. Several of the listings carried Amazon's Choice flags and used seller names such as Paizo2 which added to the confusion.
Commenters reported the problem appeared when searching for the Player Core, Game Master Core, and Monster Core, with multiple users noting similar search results. The original poster included visual evidence and community replies multiplied over the following days. A Paizo staff reply appeared in later comments, indicating the company was at least aware of the thread.
This matters for anyone buying Paizo books because edition and format affect content, layout, and price expectations. Pocket editions are smaller and formatted differently from full sized core books, and an unclear listing can lead to disappointment or the need to return an item. The community reaction focused on practical responses rather than outrage, with users sharing ways to verify listings and steps to report suspect entries.
Verify ISBN and edition details before purchasing. Look for explicit pocket or edition text in the product title and description, compare UPC or ISBN numbers against published Paizo information, and examine product images carefully for clear edition indicators. Check seller credibility and feedback if the seller name looks unofficial. If a price looks unusually low for a core book verify that the listing matches the edition you expect.
Report suspect listings to Amazon through the report an item or report incorrect product information options, and contact Paizo through official support channels to alert them to problematic seller names or misleading entries. Community vigilance matters because rapid reporting can help remove incorrect listings and reduce future confusion.
For now double check any Paizo core book purchase on Amazon to confirm the edition you want, and use ISBN or UPC comparison as your primary safeguard. The Reddit thread showed the community can spot patterns quickly, and careful verification will keep purchases aligned with expectations.
Know something we missed? Have a correction or additional information?
Submit a Tip
