Key West police arrest MMA fighter in street sexual battery case

A naked mixed martial arts fighter was accused of sexually battering a woman in the street on Key West’s late-night strip before the scene was broken up by the manager of a nearby club who saw what was happening and stepped in.

Key West police arrested the fighter, later identified as Logan Storley, on Monday, May 18, 2026, on one count of sexual battery. The alleged assault unfolded in the early-morning hours near Teasers, the strip club at 218 Duval St. that backs into Telegraph Lane, putting the case squarely in one of the city’s busiest nightlife corridors.

Investigators said several Teasers employees witnessed the incident. Police also took the woman to a health clinic for a sexual-assault examination. Storley refused to speak with officers without an attorney, according to the later reporting based on the police account.

The arrest immediately reverberated beyond Monroe County because Storley is a well-known name in combat sports. The Professional Fighters League lists him as 33, 5-foot-9 and 170 pounds, born and raised in Roslyn, South Dakota, and fighting out of Webster, South Dakota. The league’s profile says he held an 18-4 professional record at the time of the arrest and had notable wins over Michael Page, Neiman Gracie and Brennan Ward. It also describes him as a six-time South Dakota state wrestling champion and a four-time NCAA Division I All-American.

For Key West, the case underscored how quickly a chaotic scene in the Duval Street entertainment district can become a major law-enforcement matter. The area draws tourists, workers and residents deep into the night, and the police account points to a confrontation that moved from a street-level disturbance to a felony sexual-battery arrest in minutes.

The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office notes that arrest pages show arrests, not convictions. Storley now enters the criminal-justice process facing a serious charge that will be tested in court, while the city’s nightlife corridor once again sits at the center of a case with both local and national attention.