Mud Hens return to .500 with 5-2 win over Indians
A three-run first and Matt Seelinger's three clean innings steadied Toledo, pushing the Mud Hens back to .500 and flipping the series tone.
Toledo found the reset it needed at Fifth Third Field, beating Indianapolis 5-2 on May 21 and climbing back to 24-24. After a stretch of tight games, the Mud Hens finally played a clean enough night to stop the slide and claim a result that mattered more than a single line in the standings.
Matt Seelinger supplied the anchor. He worked 3.0 scoreless innings, allowed one hit and struck out four, giving Toledo the kind of early stability that has been missing in the closer games. The Mud Hens did not have to chase the matchup, and they did not have to lean too hard on the bullpen. Yoniel Curet closed it out for the save, and Toledo used eight pitchers overall to finish the job.
The real tone-setter came immediately. Toledo scored four runs across the first two innings, including a three-run first that put Indianapolis on the back foot before the Indians could settle in. One early error helped open the door, and the Mud Hens walked through it instead of wasting the chance. In a Triple-A season built on avoiding the bad inning, that was the difference between a manageable night and another scramble.
Max Clark gave the box score its sharpest swing with a double in the scoring sequence that pushed Toledo’s fifth run across. The lineup behind him did enough to cash in the opening, with Eduardo Valencia, Corey Julks, Jace Jung, Tyler Gentry, Ben Malgeri, Max Anderson, Andrew Navigato, Max Burt, Nick Yorke, Davis Wendzel, Tyler Callihan and Ronny Simon all part of the mix. Indianapolis starter Hunter Barco was charged with three unearned runs in just 1.0 inning, a quick collapse that made the early damage stick.
The Indians still created traffic. Nick Cimillo went 2-for-3 with a walk, and Termarr Johnson drew three walks, but Indianapolis never erased the first-inning hole. That was the point of the night for Toledo: no late rescue act, no bullpen fire drill, just a starter who gave length, an offense that struck first and a record that moved back to even. The series would keep shifting after that, but this was the game that steadied the Mud Hens and changed the mood in the dugout.
This article was produced by Prism’s automated news system from verified source data, official records, and press releases, then run through automated quality and moderation checks before publishing. The system is built and supervised by the people who set the standards it runs under. Read our full AI policy.
Did this article answer your question?
