Jasmine Goode and Melissa Carelli marry in elegant New Jersey wedding

Jasmine Goode and Melissa Carelli turned Crossed Keys Estate in Andover, New Jersey, into a study in contrast on Saturday, June 13, layering lace drama, pearlescent sheen and black-tie polish across the 20-plus-acre property. The Valley stars kept the ceremony romantic and the styling distinct: Jasmine wore a strapless Valentini lace gown with a dramatic train, veil and matching lace gloves, while Melissa chose a strapless column gown with a veil pinned into her updo.

The smartest move was refusing to match. Jasmine’s partial sleeves and gloves brought a vintage, hand-finished feel, while Melissa’s clean column line read modern and spare; both stayed in the same white register, but the silhouettes did the differentiating. The Wedding Plan & Co., the Hoboken firm founded by Jacquelyn Aleece, framed the day with an outdoor ceremony, a black-tie reception and a wedding party dressed in black, a crisp contrast that let the gowns read even more sculptural against the historic estate about an hour from New York City.

That balance of polish and intimacy tracked with the couple’s own brief. Melissa said they wanted the day to feel “warm, intentional and personal,” with every detail chosen with meaning, and the result felt elegant and timeless without tipping into spectacle. Goode and Carelli had been together for five years after first meeting in 2016 at The Gate in Maplewood, New Jersey, reuniting in 2020 and getting engaged in 2024 after both proposed in Italy. After the wedding, they planned a small trip soon after the celebration, followed by a larger honeymoon, likely to Africa, in the fall.

The guest list gave the wedding extra heat, with Bravo and Bachelor Nation figures including Scheana Shay, Brock Davies, Brittany Cartwright, Kristen Doute, Luke Broderick, Tom Schwartz, Danny Booko, Zack Wickham, Benji Quach, Kiana Carroll, Jesse Lally, Janet and Jason Caperna, Nia Sanchez, Alexis Waters, Jaimi King, Danielle Lombard, Brittany Paige Farrar and Rachel Lindsay on hand. Jasmine said seeing Melissa walk down the aisle was her favorite moment, while Melissa called being surrounded by all of their favorite people together “everything she had dreamed of.” The celebration landed as The Valley season 3 was still airing, and Goode later nodded on Instagram to the New York Knicks ending a 53-year championship drought, a small pop-culture coda to a wedding built on clearly edited glamour.