NHS pilot could offer miscarriage support after just one loss
Women in England still need three miscarriages before NHS care, but a pilot found graded support could prevent 10,075 losses a year and save over £40 million.
Women who lose one pregnancy are still being asked to wait through two more miscarriages before the NHS offers specialist support or pre-conception advice. That threshold, which Birmingham Women’s and Children’s NHS Foundation Trust said was still in place in July 2023, is now under pressure from a pilot that suggests earlier intervention could prevent thousands of future losses and ease pressure on the health service.
The government’s Pregnancy Loss Review, published on 22 July 2023, laid out the scale of the problem in stark numbers. It estimated around 250,000 pregnancies end in miscarriage each year in the UK and said pregnancy loss before 24 weeks affects around 1 in 5 women. The review also recorded about 11,000 hospital admissions a year for ectopic pregnancy losses, 19,000 for molar pregnancies and about 3,300 medical terminations for serious fetal anomaly in 2021. It made 73 recommendations, including a more consistent, compassionate model of care and earlier support for families.
The review also found that too many women were left to navigate grief and uncertainty alone, reporting little or no emotional support or mental-health screening after pregnancy loss. Some described being bounced between GPs, 111, A&E, gynaecology and maternity services. Others recounted distressing instructions, including being told to retrieve remains from toilets or keep them at home until local units reopened.
At the centre of the proposed shift is a graded model of care developed through research at Tommy’s National Centre for Miscarriage Research and Birmingham Women’s Hospital. It recommends advice and screening after one miscarriage, a nurse- or midwife-led clinic after two, and consultant-led care after three. Professor Arri Coomarasamy, director of Tommy’s National Centre for Miscarriage Research, said there was “no scientific logic” behind waiting for three miscarriages before treatment, comparing it to not waiting for three heart attacks before acting.
The case for change was already building before the review. In 2021, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists consulted on draft guidance recommending supportive information after one miscarriage, a miscarriage clinic after two and full investigations after three. Tommy’s says the graded model could be rolled out as a national miscarriage care package across the UK.
The latest pilot data strengthens the argument on both clinical and financial grounds. A 2026 report said the graded model could prevent around 10,075 miscarriages a year and save the NHS more than £40 million after one year. The study involved 203 women receiving graded care and 203 receiving standard care. Among those in the graded-care group, 86% had at least one future-risk factor identified, compared with 58% in standard care. One in five women with two losses were found to have thyroid problems or anaemia that would not usually have been picked up at that stage.
Scotland has already moved further, unveiling a 2024 miscarriage-care framework backed by £1.5 million and promising graded care without waiting for a third loss. The direction of travel is clear: earlier support is being tested not just as a humane response, but as a policy that could prevent miscarriages, improve equity and prove affordable at national scale.
Know something we missed? Have a correction or additional information?
Submit a Tip
